
By Aaron Hurlburt · Last reviewed 2026-10-17
Pay when something breaks, or pay monthly to keep it from breaking? How the two IT support models differ, who each fits, and what to ask before you sign.
Break-fix is the traditional model. When a computer dies, the email stops working or the network goes down, you call a technician and pay for the time and parts. Between calls, nobody is watching your systems.
Managed IT is a monthly agreement. A provider looks after a defined set of devices and services, usually with monitoring, patching, backups, a help desk and a set response time. You pay whether or not anything breaks, and the provider's job is to keep things from breaking.
A very small office with a few computers, cloud email and no server can do fine with break-fix, especially if someone on staff is comfortable handling updates and passwords. The cost is easy to understand: you pay only when you need help.
The risks are what nobody is doing in the meantime. Updates get skipped, backups quietly fail, and when something breaks during your busiest week, you wait in line behind the technician's other customers.
Managed IT tends to fit once you depend on technology to open the doors each morning: a point-of-sale system, practice management software, shared files, phones that run over the internet, or customer data you're responsible for protecting. Medical, dental, legal and financial offices usually have extra rules about how data is stored and who can see it.
The value is predictability. A fixed monthly scope, a help desk your staff can call, and someone accountable for backups and security updates. The trade-off is that you pay every month, so the scope has to be clear.
In Tampa Bay, IT planning has to include hurricanes. Ask any provider how your data is backed up, where the backup copies live, and how quickly you could work from somewhere else if your office loses power for a week. A backup that sits on a drive in the same closet as the server isn't much help after a flood.
Test a restore at least once a year. A backup you've never restored is a guess.
Whichever model you choose, cover the basics: multi-factor authentication on email and banking, automatic updates, unique passwords with a password manager, backups kept separate from your network, and short staff training on phishing. Free guidance from NIST and the U.S. Small Business Administration is written for small businesses and worth an hour of your time.
What exactly is covered: which devices, software, users and locations? What's the response time, and is it the time to answer or the time to fix? What costs extra, such as projects, new equipment or after-hours visits? Who owns the admin passwords and accounts, and how do we get them back if we leave? How long is the term, and what does it take to cancel?
Ask for a written scope and a sample monthly report. If a provider can't explain what they'll do each month in plain language, keep looking.
Some providers offer block hours or a light monitoring plan with break-fix rates for everything else. For a growing business, that can bridge the gap until a full managed plan makes sense. Cabling, Wi-Fi and phone system projects are often quoted separately either way.
If you're leaning toward a monthly plan, compare managed IT services side by side and ask how cybersecurity, backups and business phone systems are covered. The SBA has a free small business cybersecurity guide that makes a good checklist for those calls.
Break-fix means paying per repair when something goes wrong. Managed IT is a monthly agreement where a provider monitors and maintains your systems to prevent problems.
It often is once your business depends on systems every day or handles customer data. Very small offices on cloud tools may do fine with break-fix.
A clear list of covered devices and services, response times, what costs extra, who owns the admin accounts, and how to cancel.